A U.S. appellate court has delivered a significant legal blow to prediction market platforms, affirming Maryland’s statutory authority to enforce its state sports wagering laws against Kalshi. The decision marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing jurisdictional tug-of-war between federal commodities regulation and traditional state-level oversight of gambling and betting activities.
In a per curiam opinion issued in case No. 25-1892, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled that the federal Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) does not explicitly preempt state gaming laws. Crucially, the court found that this lack of preemption holds true even when applied to event contracts hosted on a designated contract market that operates under the direct regulatory oversight of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
The appellate decision, finalized on November 18, 2026, following oral arguments heard earlier on May 7, 2026, effectively rejects Kalshi’s core legal arguments. The platform had contended that its federal designation as a contract market shielded it from state-level gambling restrictions and enforcement actions. However, the Fourth Circuit panel found no indication of statutory conflict, concluding that state enforcement does not create an impossibility or serve as an impermissible obstacle to achieving federal legislative objectives.
Amplifying the court’s reasoning, Judge Roger L. Gregory authored a concurring opinion that underscored the historic legal boundaries of state authority. He emphasized that the regulation of gambling and wagering has long fallen squarely within the domain of traditional state police powers.
"Because the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, I would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland’s concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so," Judge Gregory wrote, highlighting the high legal bar required for federal preemption in areas historically managed by local governments.
The ruling has drawn immediate praise from state regulatory leaders who view the decision as a vital safeguard for consumers. Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown welcomed the appellate court’s mandate, asserting that the decision ensures all platforms offering wagers to state residents are held to identical regulatory and consumer protection benchmarks.
"When betting platforms operate outside State oversight, Marylanders lose the protections that keep gambling fair and safe," Attorney General Brown said in a formal statement responding to the Fourth Circuit’s decision. "Today’s ruling means Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents."
The legal battle highlights a broader, nationwide tension within the financial and legal sectors as prediction markets increasingly offer event-based contracts that closely mirror traditional sports betting and political wagering. While entities like Kalshi maintain that their products function as federally regulated financial derivatives, state regulators across the country have grown increasingly concerned about the proliferation of retail betting platforms operating outside the well-established consumer protection frameworks governing local sportsbooks and casinos.
With the Fourth Circuit upholding Maryland’s enforcement authority, the decision could serve as a persuasive precedent for other states seeking to regulate or restrict similar prediction market activities within their borders. For Maryland consumers, the ruling reinforces that digital wagering platforms—regardless of their federal regulatory status—must navigate state compliance channels if they wish to market their services to local residents.

Comments (0)