Arthur Hayes, the co-founder and former CEO of cryptocurrency derivatives exchange BitMEX, says he is feeling "flattered" by Coinbase’s recent legal maneuverings in a high-stakes US federal court battle concerning stock perpetual futures. The ongoing legal dispute highlights a rapidly evolving regulatory battleground over how innovative financial instruments are classified and traded within the United States.
When BitMEX originally pioneered the perpetual swap back in 2016, introducing a revolutionary product that allowed cryptocurrency traders to maintain leveraged positions without a fixed expiration date, the reaction from Washington regulators was anything but welcoming. The product went on to become a foundational staple of the broader digital asset trading ecosystem, transforming liquidity and derivative markets globally.
Nearly a decade later, major mainstream digital asset companies like Coinbase are now in federal court actively defending the right to offer strikingly similar products tied directly to traditional US equities. Reflecting on this monumental shift in industry dynamics, Hayes remarked to Cointelegraph that imitation truly is the sincerest form of regulation.
The legal controversy intensified when Coinbase, alongside five other industry firms, submitted an amicus curiae brief on Monday. This legal filing formally opposed a request by the Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA) to block trading in perpetual futures products tied to individual company stocks. The federal court formally accepted the brief on Tuesday, setting the stage for a broader debate on financial innovation and regulatory oversight.
The Capital Markets Alliance Association initiated the lawsuit with the core argument that these novel stock perpetual contracts should properly be classified as security-based swaps. Under existing financial regulations, security-based swaps face significantly tighter restrictions, particularly regarding retail investor access and participation.
During his tenure as CEO of BitMEX, Hayes played a central role in popularizing the Bitcoin perpetual swap. By eliminating the need for traders to roll over expiring futures contracts, the instrument streamlined leveraged trading and fundamentally reshaped modern market structure. The recent expansion of these concepts into traditional equity markets has drawn immediate scrutiny from both regulatory agencies and traditional financial institutions.
SEC weighs in on stock perpetuals
The regulatory landscape surrounding these products grew even more complex as the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) reportedly submitted a proposed court brief on Monday. The agency’s filing voiced opposition to the alliance’s ongoing request to temporarily halt the trading of these controversial equity-linked contracts.
In its submission, the SEC indicated that it is currently reviewing the specific exchange rules established for listing these contracts. However, the regulatory brief intentionally left open critical questions regarding whether the commission might eventually set those rules aside, and whether the contracts formally qualify as traditional security futures or security-based swaps under federal law.
In a subsequent court filing submitted on Tuesday, the CMAA argued that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) had approved the contracts hastily without providing an adequate explanation for its decision-making process or addressing deeply unresolved regulatory questions.
Furthermore, the alliance highlighted massive early adoption metrics as evidence of market disruption. The group cited approximately $375 million in reported 24-hour notional trading volume for Kalshi’s stock perpetual products shortly after their official launch, asserting that these innovative products were already actively diverting substantial business away from traditional stock markets and established exchanges.
Stock perpetuals’ lack of expiry is at issue
At the very heart of the legal dispute is the defining characteristic of stock perpetuals: their complete lack of a fixed expiration date. These specialized financial instruments allow market participants to speculate on the price movements of individual company shares without requiring them to ever own or take physical delivery of the underlying equities.
On November 3, US District Judge Valerie Caproni denied the alliance’s initial request for a temporary restraining order. The judge ruled that the group had failed to adequately demonstrate the likelihood of sustaining immediate, irreparable harm. However, Judge Caproni did note that the alliance demonstrated a reasonable likelihood of ultimately succeeding on its central legal claim that the CFTC may have exceeded its statutory authority in approving the contracts.
Wojciech Kaszycki, a strategy adviser to BTCS SA, pointed out that the absence of a fixed expiration or delivery date fundamentally complicates the legal argument surrounding whether perpetual contracts can properly be classified as standard futures under existing statutory definitions.
Kaszycki explained to Cointelegraph that the core of the legal debate centers on whether these instruments constitute a legitimate "sale for future delivery." At the same time, he issued a stern warning that a definitive legal ruling against the CFTC could produce unintended consequences, potentially driving trading activity entirely away from regulated domestic venues and straight toward offshore and decentralized trading platforms.
Emphasizing the borderless nature of modern financial technology, Kaszycki noted that the product does not simply die when faced with regulatory hurdles; rather, it simply changes address.

Comments (0)