There may well be a "Secret Sant-AI" orchestrating your holiday presents this year, as a growing number of consumers turn to artificial intelligence to handle the heavy lifting of festive gift-giving. According to new research released by Visa, roughly 41% of Americans admit they would keep it to themselves if AI played a role in selecting a gift for a loved one. This quiet delegation reflects a broader cultural shift, as shoppers increasingly hand off the tedious tasks of finding ideal presents and tracking down elusive deals to automated systems.
Data from the study shows that more than half of U.S. adults—specifically 54%—have already utilized artificial intelligence for at least one shopping-related task this season. This represents a noticeable upward tick from the 47% who reported doing so during the previous holiday shopping cycle.
These findings stem from Visa’s comprehensive 2026 Holiday Spending Shift Survey. Conducted via polling of more than 1,000 U.S. adults in late September by research firm Morning Consult, the survey paints a vivid portrait of modern consumers navigating a complex economic landscape. Today’s shoppers are simultaneously juggling persistent cost-of-living pressures, rapidly evolving technological tools, and heightened concerns regarding digital fraud, all while striving to check every single item off their holiday gift lists.
Michael Brown, principal U.S. economist at Visa, notes that consumers are approaching the holiday season with a dual focus on value and security. According to Brown, people are actively seeking out bargains, experimenting with emerging tools like generative artificial intelligence, and fundamentally changing how they shop in direct response to evolving fraud concerns. It paints the picture of a resilient consumer base adapting as the retail experience itself continues to transform at a breakneck pace.
AI Becomes a Holiday Helper
When it comes to practical applications, shoppers have demonstrated the highest levels of comfort handing over logistical and administrative chores to artificial intelligence. Prominent use cases include comparing prices across different merchants, which 61% of respondents are open to, checking product availability at 59%, tracking down discounts and promotional codes at 57%, and generating creative gift suggestions at 54%. Furthermore, nearly a quarter of consumers report that they feel significantly more comfortable utilizing AI for their shopping routines than they did just one year ago.
Generative artificial intelligence is finding its most enthusiastic adoption among younger demographics, with Generation Z leading the charge. More than eight out of ten young consumers express an openness to receiving AI assistance during their shopping journeys. Notably, 73% of Gen Z respondents would welcome AI-driven gift suggestions, a figure that sits a full 19 percentage points higher than the general adult population.
Despite this enthusiasm for digital discovery, a distinct gap remains between browsing and actual purchasing. While consumers are increasingly eager to employ AI assistants for research, price comparison, and decision-making support, trusting an autonomous algorithm to complete a financial transaction on their behalf represents a much higher hurdle. According to data from the Visa Trust Index, only 23% of U.S. consumers currently trust generative AI to handle payment transactions on their behalf.
This hesitation follows a familiar historical pattern where new technology arrives and gains traction in daily routines well before consumers develop full trust in the underlying experience. Industry observers note a parallel to the early days of e-commerce when payments first moved online, and later when retail transactions shifted onto mobile devices.
Bridging this trust gap often comes down to brand familiarity and perceived security. The Visa Trust Index revealed that 61% of consumers place their trust in established payment networks like Visa to properly secure an AI-powered payment. This confidence climbs even higher among specific segments, reaching 68% for adults aged 18 to 34 and 71% among frequent users of artificial intelligence technology. As agentic commerce continues its gradual expansion across the digital economy, this foundational consumer confidence may serve as the vital bridge that transforms AI from a simple shopping assistant into a trusted purchasing agent.
Shoppers Stretch Budgets as Costs Stay Top of Mind
Even as technological tools evolve, cost-conscious behavior remains a defining characteristic of the modern holiday shopping season. Economic pressures are far from absent, with 84% of consumers reporting that they have taken at least one deliberate action to manage higher everyday costs over the past year. The most common strategies include actively hunting for discounts and coupons, cited by 47% of respondents, cutting back on discretionary spending at 35%, and trading down to more affordable, lower-cost brands at 33%.
Experiences Top Wish Lists, But Physical Gifts Win Wallets
Beyond basic cash gifts, Americans’ holiday wish lists reveal a strong collective appetite for memorable experiences. Travel and vacations, selected by 60% of respondents, and live-event tickets, chosen by 55%, top the list of what people are most excited to either give or receive during the festivities.
However, the reality of actual holiday purchasing tells a markedly different story. When wallets are finally opened, only 15% of respondents prioritize purchasing experiential gifts, while 27% focus their spending on traditional physical items. Generation Z comes closest to aligning their purchasing power with their expressed wishes, with 39% splitting their holiday spending evenly between experiences and physical goods, compared to just 26% of adults overall.
FIFA World Cup 2026 Fever Shapes Gift-Giving
The upcoming global sporting landscape is also leaving a tangible footprint on holiday gift lists this year. Nearly a third of Americans report that the anticipation surrounding the FIFA World Cup 2026 has noticeably boosted their interest in purchasing sports-related merchandise and gifts. This enthusiasm is even more pronounced among higher-income households earning $100,000 or more, as well as adults under the age of 35, where roughly half express heightened interest in sports-themed gifting.
Cross-Border Shopping Goes Mainstream
The scope of holiday shopping is expanding geographically as well. Three in ten Americans expect to purchase at least one gift from an overseas seller during the current season. Among Gen Z consumers, that proportion jumps to more than half, highlighting a growing comfort with international e-commerce platforms.
Interestingly, lower prices are not the primary driver for this global shift. While better deals motivate 25% of cross-border shoppers, product quality, cited by 32%, and unique craftsmanship, cited by 31%, emerge as the top reasons consumers are looking far beyond U.S. borders for their holiday needs.
Gen Z and Cross-Border Senders Warm to Stablecoins and Crypto
As cross-border shopping and global transactions grow more common, alternative financial technologies are gaining traction among specific consumer groups. While stablecoins remain relatively novel to the broader American public, more than half of respondents—56%—recognize at least one clear benefit to their use, a figure that surges to 77% among Gen Z. Furthermore, among Americans who regularly send money across international borders, 51% indicate that after learning about the associated benefits, they are likely to utilize stablecoins within the coming year.
Cryptocurrency resonates similarly within these specific demographics. Half of all respondents who send money abroad describe crypto as a useful mechanism for international transfers, compared to just 26% of adults generally. Additionally, Gen Z demonstrates greater comfort shopping with online retailers that accept cryptocurrency, with 34% expressing willingness compared to 25% of the wider adult population.
Fraud Concerns Drive Behavior Change
The undeniable convenience of digital shopping and automated tools inevitably brings heightened unease regarding digital scams, security breaches, and fraudulent activity. Nearly three in ten shoppers report that they were personally targeted by fraudulent schemes during the previous holiday shopping season, a vulnerability that climbs to 39% among the younger Gen Z demographic.
In response to these persistent threats, three-quarters of Americans have actively altered their daily shopping habits and security practices. Common protective measures include enabling two-factor authentication on accounts, practiced by 34% of respondents, changing online account passwords with greater frequency at 34%, declining to save payment card details on merchant websites at 25%, switching from debit cards to more secure credit cards at 24%, and relying more heavily on digital wallets at 21%.
Reflecting on the overarching mood of the season, Michael Brown emphasizes that consumers are successfully navigating a complicated array of challenges this year, ranging from stubborn cost pressures and novel technologies to genuine apprehensions regarding fraud. Despite these hurdles, consumers continue to adapt through diligent deal-hunting, smarter purchasing strategies, and heightened personal vigilance.

Comments (0)