This is a segment from The Breakdown newsletter. To read full editions, subscribe.
Arboreal ecosystems operate on a brutal but necessary paradox: For a forest to grow, it occasionally needs to burn. Without these seemingly apocalyptic conflagrations, the forest floor becomes choked with underbrush, preventing the new growth needed for regeneration and long-term viability.
Dion Lim says this is how technology cycles work, too.
“The first web cycle,” he explains, “burned through dot-com exuberance and left behind Google, Amazon, eBay, and PayPal: the hardy survivors of Web 1.0. The next cycle, driven by social and mobile, burned again in 2008-2009, clearing the underbrush for Facebook, Airbnb, Uber, and the offspring of Y Combinator.”
The speculative frenzy of investment bubbles burns off non-productive capital much like a wildfire consumes dense fuel, and the inevitable market crash clears the way for resources to be reallocated efficiently. Without these market conflagrations, a permanent underbrush of failed startups would drain the technology sector of the resources it desperately needs to grow.
This underlying dynamic may explain why the cryptocurrency sector feels uniquely left behind this current market cycle. Instead of a healthy clearing out of obsolete models, a tangled undergrowth of legacy projects that never seem to die has been hoarding the scarce resources the ecosystem needs to evolve.
In the traditional real economy, labor and intellectual capital are constantly being reallocated from failed companies to successful or promising ones. “Many of Google’s best early employees,” Lim notes, “were founders or early employees of failed Web 1.0 startups.”
This natural recycling of human capital happens far less frequently in crypto.
To cite just one stark example, the Polkadot blockchain, which collected a mere $72 in daily fees recently, is still supported by 482 full-time developers and 1,404 contributors, according to recent developer reports and token terminal data. If a project operating in its sixth year with such minimal economic traction were funded by traditional equity rather than tokens, market forces suggest those engineering resources would have been released back into the broader tech ecosystem long ago.
This dynamic presents a major structural hurdle because of Packard’s Law, which dictates that growth in revenues cannot exceed growth in people who can execute and sustain that growth. If the scarce resource of talented crypto developers remains trapped within stagnant projects rather than being redistributed to thriving ecosystems, the broader crypto industry will inevitably struggle to scale.
Unproductive crypto projects also manage to hoard massive investment resources in ways that defy traditional market logic. Crypto founders are notoriously able to over-raise capital from early investors and comfortably live off the proceeds, largely insulated from the traditional market-imposed urgency required to find genuine product-market fit.
For instance, Golem, one of the original token-sale projects in the space, stockpiled 820,000 ether during its initial coin offering in 2016. Astonishingly, on-chain data showed the project still held 231,400 ether as recently as last year. Traditional startup investors expect their capital to be deployed purposefully and efficiently, rather than sitting idly in treasury accounts for nearly a decade.
In other cases, projects with inexplicably large market valuations fund their operations seemingly forever by continuously selling their native tokens directly out of treasury reserves. Cardano, as a prominent example, holds roughly $700 million worth of its ADA token in its treasury, providing the project with a financial runway that could theoretically last almost indefinitely without external validation.
Collectively, various crypto protocols are sitting on billions of dollars in capital reserves and face little to no economic incentive to deploy that capital efficiently. Unlike traditional corporate structures, they answer to no activist shareholders, harbor no fear of corporate raiders, and have no quarterly earnings estimates to meet. In short, large segments of the crypto industry may simply be too funded to fail.
Tech analyst Ben Thompson has recently articulated a remarkably similar fear regarding traditional Big Tech, worrying that industry giants like TSMC, Nvidia, and Alphabet have become so dominant that the entire technology sector risks long-term stagnation. He argues that this dynamic is precisely why market participants should welcome economic bubbles rather than fear them.
“What is invigorating or why we should embrace the mania, embrace the bubble, is [that] ‘too-big-to-fail’ was starting to afflict tech as well,” Thompson noted.
Thompson points out that the fundamental benefit of private enterprise is that "stupid stuff" eventually goes out of business. However, when companies become entrenched monopolies or are heavily insulated by alternative funding mechanisms, the unproductive elements do not die. Instead, they simply become over-engineered and structurally inefficient.
He argues that modern markets need investment bubbles precisely because they forcefully inject risk back into the equation. As Thompson frames it, you simply cannot achieve upside risk without enduring downside risk.
This structural immunity helps explain why the crypto industry has felt remarkably stagnant during this cycle. The ecosystem is populated with plenty of the "stupid stuff"—protocols boasting few active users and negligible revenue—yet it completely lacks the natural economic mechanisms required to force them out of business.
“Growth becomes difficult when everyone’s roots are tangled,” Lim warns.
Until a metaphorical forest fire is allowed to burn through the tangled roots of over-funded zombie protocols, vital nutrients such as venture capital and elite developer talent will remain trapped, keeping the next major era of technological growth frustratingly out of reach.

Comments (0)