BREAKING
Vercel Resolves OpenTelemetry Blind Spot in AI SDK With New Inference Duration Histogram ● YBUSDT Approaches Potential Turning Point Amid Signs of Returning Buying Interest ● SEC to Resume Processing Registration Applications ● Rarible Unveils Rebuilt Cross-Chain Marketplace Featuring High-Speed Trading and New Rewards System ● Niko Bellic Appears in GTA 6: Voice Actor Michael Hollick Returns for Late-Game Cameo ● Ant International’s Alipay+ Connects Over 50 Global E-Wallets to Brazil’s Pix to Revolutionize Cross-Border Payments ● Federal Investigation Links Ransomware Negotiation Executives to ShinyHunters Hacking Group and FBI Data Breach ● White House National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross to Step Down Amid Transitioning Political Landscape and Unexplained Tech Outages ●
Macroeconomics & Inflation

From the Penny-Farthing to the Blockchain: Why World-Changing Technologies Often Break Investors

Photo: Documentation / News Illustration

This is a segment from The Breakdown newsletter. To read full editions, subscribe via Blockworks.

“It gives women a feeling of freedom and self-reliance. I stand and rejoice every time I see a woman ride by on a wheel.”

These words, spoken by Susan B. Anthony toward the end of the nineteenth century, capture a profound societal transformation that was sparked not by political decree, but by a mechanical invention. Yet, the story of how that invention came to change the world is also a cautionary tale about financial speculation, market bubbles, and the often-painful disconnect between societal progress and investor returns.

To understand how the modern bicycle revolutionized society—and why its financial history mirrors the dilemmas facing modern technology sectors like artificial intelligence and cryptocurrency—one must look back to the turbulent manufacturing booms of the late nineteenth century.

The 1880s marked a pivotal turning point in personal mobility. Until then, bicycle riders sat directly and precariously high above the comically giant front wheel of a Victorian penny-farthing. These machines were dangerous, requiring immense balance and courage, and were largely restricted to daring athletes and wealthy hobbyists. However, the landscape of transportation shifted dramatically with the invention of chains capable of transferring pedal power directly to a bicycle’s rear wheel, leaving the front wheel solely responsible for steering.

This mechanical breakthrough was swiftly followed by other vital innovations. Diamond-shaped frames, weldless steel tubes, and pneumatic tires completed the bicycle’s rapid evolution from a dangerous novelty into the practical, efficient mode of transport and exercise that remains ubiquitous today.

The introduction of a safer, smoother, and vastly more comfortable ride was an immediate and overwhelming commercial hit. Within just a few years, bicycle manufacturing evolved into a booming global industry. The scale of this industrial expansion was staggering; in the manufacturing hub of Birmingham, England, alone, the number of registered bicycle-related manufacturers surged from 72 in 1889 to a remarkable 177 by 1895.

This explosive growth quickly sparked a manic frenzy among public investors. Financial historians who authored Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles describe this episode as a particularly clear illustration of how speculative manias can accelerate infrastructural development, even as they inflict heavy losses on participants.

Driven by unbridled optimism and FOMO, manic investors pushed an index of cycle shares up by an astonishing 258% during the first five months of 1896 alone. This meteoric rise naturally attracted a flood of new stock market listings designed to cash in on the public appetite. In the two-year span leading up to 1897, no fewer than 670 cycle, tube, or tire firms floated shares on England’s regional stock markets.

Many of these newly minted public companies were of exceptionally low quality and questionable financial foundation. A prime example was Accles Ltd., a firm that managed to sell £135,000 worth of shares to eager investors while reporting a paltry £71 in actual revenue before filing for bankruptcy less than two years later.

As financial gravity inevitably reasserted itself, cycle shares suffered a catastrophic correction. Predictably, securities in the sector lost 73% of their total value from the frenzied peak of the Bicycle Mania in the early months of 1896 through the end of 1898.

Yet, as painful as that financial washout undoubtedly was for contemporary investors, the systemic bust was arguably worth the economic collateral damage. The speculative investment bubble massively accelerated critical research and development—particularly in tire quality improvements that later laid the vital foundation for the nascent automobile industry. Furthermore, it spurred rapid advances in machine tools and ball-bearing manufacturing that rippled outward, permanently upgrading the baseline capabilities of English manufacturing and beyond.

Even more importantly, the massive flood of affordable bicycles produced during the bubble era catalyzed a modernizing effect on society that contemporary analysts could scarcely have predicted.

In Victorian society, strict social expectations dictated that women should be closely chaperoned whenever they traveled away from the home. This rigid norm was effectively shattered when bicycles became widely accessible to the general public. Chaperoning a woman on a bicycle was logistically impractical, and there were simply too many riders streaming through the streets for Victorian social enforcers to police.

This newfound mobility also sparked the “rational clothing” movement. The sheer physical impossibility of cycling while encumbered by restrictive corsets and heavy skirts forced the rapid development and adoption of more practical garments and divided skirts for women.

It is difficult for modern observers to overstate just how radical a cultural shift this represented at the time.

“Let me tell you what I think of bicycling,” Susan B. Anthony famously told the New York World in 1896. “I think it has done more to emancipate women than anything else in the world.”

Such was the deep popular association forged between feminism and cycling that the bicycle ultimately became a living symbol of the women’s suffrage movement. Women rode forward, entirely free from suffocating Victorian social norms, propelled by a booming, over-supplied market of modern bicycles. For that profound cultural leap forward, society has the overenthusiastic and ultimately burned investors of the 1890s to thank.


Invest like it’s 1999?

Decades later, legendary investor Warren Buffett articulated a harsh economic truth that echoes this historical dynamic: world-changing, paradigm-shifting technologies are frequently utterly ruinous for the investors who correctly predict their ascendance.

The automotive industry serves as a classic textbook example of this paradox. Addressing an annual gathering of VIPs and business leaders in Sun Valley, Idaho, Buffett reflected on the historical trajectory of car manufacturing.

“If you had seen at the time of the first cars how this country would develop in connection with autos,” Buffett noted, “you would have said, ‘This is the place I must be.’ But [out of] two thousand [auto] companies, as of a few years ago, only three survived… so autos had an enormous impact on America, but in the opposite direction for investors.”

Commercial aviation represents another stark illustration of the same principle. Buffett posed a similar hypothetical regarding the dawn of flight, noting that anyone observing the Wright brothers at Kitty Hawk might have concluded that aviation was the absolute definitive place to deploy capital for the future. Yet, as he pointed out decades later, the aggregate of all stock market investments made in the airline industry throughout its entire history had resulted in virtually zero net lifetime profit for investors as a whole.

That was Buffett’s characteristic way of warning audiences that they could be entirely correct in predicting that the internet would change everything about modern life, while simultaneously being entirely wrong in assuming that those technological changes would translate into lasting profits for equity holders.

True to that warning, the dotcom bubble dramatically popped just eight months later.

Today, artificial intelligence stands out as the most prominent candidate for the next world-changing technology destined to ultimately disappoint financial speculators. AI will almost certainly revolutionize nearly every facet of the global economy; however, which specific companies, if any, will successfully capture and retain the vast economic value it generates remains an open question.

Cryptocurrency faces a remarkably similar existential dilemma.

The fundamental news surrounding the broader digital asset sector has often been remarkably positive on paper. Regulatory stances have shifted, institutional adoption has expanded, prediction markets have successfully broken into the mainstream, and traditional financial institutions have increasingly scrambled to integrate blockchain technology into their operations. Yet, despite these structural tailwinds, token prices and crypto-native investment returns have frequently lagged behind fundamental adoption.

This disconnect may simply stem from a temporary mismatch where market expectations got too far ahead of underlying economic reality. However, it may also point to a deeper structural truth: regardless of how much total economic value crypto ultimately creates, very little of that value may accrue to the speculators and venture capitalists who funded its early infrastructure.

Consider the widespread excitement surrounding the tokenization of real-world assets. While the promise of bringing traditional financial assets on-chain is vast, if the vast majority of those assets are ultimately tokenized directly by established legacy giants like Robinhood, BlackRock, and the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation, the native crypto investors who financed the underlying public blockchains may capture very little of the commercial value created.

Similarly, the broader crypto industry has poured billions of dollars into developing zero-knowledge proofs, a cryptographic innovation with immense societal utility. It is easy to imagine how ZK proofs could become humanity’s primary digital defense mechanism against a flood of AI-generated misinformation and deepfakes. Yet, they may simultaneously prove to be terrible investments for tokenholders. Zero-knowledge proving is, at its core, advanced mathematics that does not inherently require a speculative, tradeable token to function or scale.

Similar dynamics apply across numerous other crypto-native sectors, largely because the foundational ethos of decentralized technology was never designed to funnel wealth into traditional extraction models.

On the contrary, the core vision of composable, open-source, decentralized crypto was specifically engineered to disintermediate the rent-seekers of the legacy technology sector and tear down the high toll booths historically maintained by traditional finance.

At the conclusion of yet another cyclical downturn in token prices, it is tempting for market participants to conclude that crypto is simply progressing too slowly toward its grand decentralization goals. But if blockchain technology ultimately proves to be as profoundly beneficial for human society as the invention of the safety bicycle, no one should genuinely complain if it also proves to be equally challenging for speculative investors.

What is your reaction to this story?

Neng Nana

Writer and contributor at Bitcoin 98.

Comments (0)